Countdown 2
  • Publish Date: Posted over 4 years ago
  • Author:by Louise Gapp

IR35: It’s the final countdown, but are we ready to deal with the consequences?

The activation date is fast approaching for the new IR35 legislation, which will hold public sector clients responsible for ensuring the compliance of their contractors. The new rules will apply to all payments after 6th April, regardless of when work was carried out. Many industry experts have questioned if the market is ready for the changes; I would dispute whether HMRC itself is prepared for the potential consequences of its new money-saving venture.\r\n\r\nCedar, like all industry representatives, is sympathetic to the aim of preventing tax avoidance; official reports describe losses of £400million attributed to personal services companies (‘PSCs’). However, the updated IR35 legislation has faced justified criticism for the danger it poses to the vitality of the UK’s flexible workforce. Given widespread suspicion that similar legislation will be inevitably rolled out to private sector contractors in the near future, it is not unreasonable to consider IR35 a threat to the future of all flexible working.\r\n\r\nAlongside the changes announced in the 2016 Budget was an assurance of the Treasury’s commitment to develop a “clearer and simpler set of tests and online tools”, helping businesses check the IR35 compliance of contractors. HMRC’s new assessment tool, presumably an updated version of the Employment Status Indicator, is projected to launch in February or March, alarmingly near to the April activation date. Early communications suggest that the tool will likely classify the vast majority of assignments as inside IR35, and many are concerned that it will be inevitably biased towards collecting as much tax as possible. It is also possible that the tool may be ignored by risk-averse public sector bodies, who may favour all-encompassing policy changes rather than bearing the risk of miscategorising. The recent decision by Transport for London (‘TfL’) to impose a blanket ban on contractors operating as PSCs, effective from 17th February, suggests early evidence for this trend.\r\n\r\nEven if other public sector bodies do not follow TfL’s example, the impact of their new tax responsibilities, and likely rise in contractor day rates, will place further strain on already-struggling organisations. With increased pressure on the public sector from austerity, as well as financial and political uncertainty, a flexible workforce is even more crucial. As well as threatening the viability of their work, HMRC’s renewed targeting of PSCs suggests an accusatory feeling towards contractors, who provide much-needed support in both public and private sectors. Cedar anticipates that amid the uncertainty of Brexit and global political upheaval, many businesses will be eager to recruit interim experts and advisors to guide them. IR35, especially if extended to the private sector, will complicate this process, and recruiters’ roles in facilitating it, potentially damaging the resilience of the UK economy.\r\n\r\nLike other industry representatives, I am fearful that IR35 signals the beginning of the end for temporary contractors in the public sector. Although its aim is to save the government money is noble, I doubt if this expectation can be realistic, given the projected damage to the flexible workforce. It is unclear how HMRC intends to handle the pushback likely to arise from unfair classification challenges, and indeed whether it will have the resources and personnel to do so effectively. Despite HMRC’s best efforts to ease the blow with new technology, IR35 could be a step back for the modern world of work, making the future seem more uncertain than ever.\r\n\r\nAre you ready for IR35? We’d love to know what you think.\r\n\r\n \r\n\r\nDisclaimer: The issues discussed here are not exhaustive; Cedar would advise businesses to seek independent financial and legal help to determine tax status and decide on future action.\r\n\r\n \r\n

Share this Article
Back to Blogs
The activation date is fast approaching for the new IR35 legislation, which will hold public sector clients responsible for ensuring the compliance of their contractors. The new rules will apply to all payments after 6th April, regardless of when work was carried out. Many industry experts have questioned if the market is ready for the changes; I would dispute whether HMRC itself is prepared for the potential consequences of its new money-saving venture.\r\n\r\nCedar, like all industry representatives, is sympathetic to the aim of preventing tax avoidance; official reports describe losses of £400million attributed to personal services companies (‘PSCs’). However, the updated IR35 legislation has faced justified criticism for the danger it poses to the vitality of the UK’s flexible workforce. Given widespread suspicion that similar legislation will be inevitably rolled out to private sector contractors in the near future, it is not unreasonable to consider IR35 a threat to the future of all flexible working.\r\n\r\nAlongside the changes announced in the 2016 Budget was an assurance of the Treasury’s commitment to develop a “clearer and simpler set of tests and online tools”, helping businesses check the IR35 compliance of contractors. HMRC’s new assessment tool, presumably an updated version of the Employment Status Indicator, is projected to launch in February or March, alarmingly near to the April activation date. Early communications suggest that the tool will likely classify the vast majority of assignments as inside IR35, and many are concerned that it will be inevitably biased towards collecting as much tax as possible. It is also possible that the tool may be ignored by risk-averse public sector bodies, who may favour all-encompassing policy changes rather than bearing the risk of miscategorising. The recent decision by Transport for London (‘TfL’) to impose a blanket ban on contractors operating as PSCs, effective from 17th February, suggests early evidence for this trend.\r\n\r\nEven if other public sector bodies do not follow TfL’s example, the impact of their new tax responsibilities, and likely rise in contractor day rates, will place further strain on already-struggling organisations. With increased pressure on the public sector from austerity, as well as financial and political uncertainty, a flexible workforce is even more crucial. As well as threatening the viability of their work, HMRC’s renewed targeting of PSCs suggests an accusatory feeling towards contractors, who provide much-needed support in both public and private sectors. Cedar anticipates that amid the uncertainty of Brexit and global political upheaval, many businesses will be eager to recruit interim experts and advisors to guide them. IR35, especially if extended to the private sector, will complicate this process, and recruiters’ roles in facilitating it, potentially damaging the resilience of the UK economy.\r\n\r\nLike other industry representatives, I am fearful that IR35 signals the beginning of the end for temporary contractors in the public sector. Although its aim is to save the government money is noble, I doubt if this expectation can be realistic, given the projected damage to the flexible workforce. It is unclear how HMRC intends to handle the pushback likely to arise from unfair classification challenges, and indeed whether it will have the resources and personnel to do so effectively. Despite HMRC’s best efforts to ease the blow with new technology, IR35 could be a step back for the modern world of work, making the future seem more uncertain than ever.\r\n\r\nAre you ready for IR35? We’d love to know what you think.\r\n\r\n \r\n\r\nDisclaimer: The issues discussed here are not exhaustive; Cedar would advise businesses to seek independent financial and legal help to determine tax status and decide on future action.\r\n\r\n \r\n

Latest Blogs

View All Blogs
square peg
Square pegs, round holes…and the need for genuine tax expertise in your business

As you know, the government has an Office for Tax Simplification, set up by George Osborne after he became Chancellor of the Exchequer in 2010. Unfortunately, as a former tax director from Grant...

Blank
​Recruitment as we move into Q4 – it’s a battlefield and a buyer’s market

Last year, as the full extent of the pandemic, became apparent, many economists said it would take a long time for the economy to recover. In April 2020, The Guardian reported that the EY Item Club...

Screen Shot 2018 07 12 At 3
What it takes to be a successful PE portfolio company CEO

​Whilst there is not a one size fits all solution for what we see in successful PE portfolio company CEO’s we are able to see some clear trends when it comes this. Below we have attempted to answer...

Image 790ea9f990
How to Make Your CV Stand Out

Looking for your next finance role? The first step is getting your CV right. With such a small window in which to impress recruiters, it’s vital that you’re able to make your CV stand out from the ...

Cover Wave 1200x628
A new wave of Executive Search

​Cedar Recruitment is, as we’re sure you know, a well-established, highly successful recruitment business. Our reputation was initially built on our expertise in accountancy and financial services...

Image 70a5eb1f6f
Public Practice Priorities for the year(s) ahead

Just over a year ago, we were starting to learn about a strange illness that was causing people to die in a number of countries - China, Italy and then, in small numbers at first, the UK. If you Go...

Picture1
How Covid-19 has changed company cultures.

​We are coming up to 12 months of working from home and company culture is one of the biggest things that has changed in our working environment.From a recruitment perspective, one of the most comm...

Image C3446935a3
Temperature Check – Recruitment in 2021

As we close on 2020, supposedly the year of clarity (20/20 vision) what do our Consultants see the future holding.Despite the threat of a 2nd mutated strain arriving at our shores and the likelihoo...

Scrooge
"I don’t make merry myself at Christmas" [sic]

​Scrooge was a much-misunderstood man. That thought may be behind the statement by Julien Lenglet, Head of the Antony Hospital in Paris, who believes that festive celebrations could lead to a surge...

Image 67889e23f0
All Change: pandemic winners and losers

This has been a truly extraordinary year for businesses. For the recruitment industry as much as any other, Covid-19 has been more devastating than anything in living memory. Over 500 million jobs ...

Recovery
4 successful strategies for securing talent during the global recovery

Over the last five months, organisations across the globe have made extraordinary changes in their working practices in response to COVID 19 and Talent Acquisition has been no exception. Whilst man...

Image 39dd5aed8f
Baby birds, jobs data and the future of recruitment…

Like baby birds in a nest, the different sectors of the economy are straining to be fed, their mouths open and begging the Chancellor to attend to their needs first. However, nature, as we know, is...

Image Cb9c7c2608
Procurement – at the heart of the crisis and the centre of the recovery

Public sector, especially NHS, procurement has been at the centre of the coronavirus crisis, perhaps for the first time bringing the general public an awareness of what procurement itself is all ab...